Top Pick at a Glance
If you’re like me and obsessed with Sol de Janeiro Cheirosa 62 but not in love with the price tag, I’ve got good news. After extensive testing, The Body Shop Vanilla Pumpkin emerges as the top dupe. It nails that warm pistachio-salted caramel-vanilla blend with surprising depth. Plus, it lasts all day. I always recommend checking the current price on Amazon before buying, as it often goes on sale.
Check the current price on Amazon
The Body Shop Vanilla Pumpkin
Notes: Pistachio, salted caramel, vanilla, pumpkin, cinnamon. Who it is for: Anyone who wants the closest match to Cheirosa 62 with better longevity. Great for fall and winter, but wearable year-round. Verdict: Best Overall
This is the one that made me do a double take. It hits the same sweet, nutty, and gourmand notes as the original, with an extra hint of pumpkin spice that makes it even cozier. The body spray concentration means you can layer it without overwhelming. I spray it on my clothes and hair, and it lasts through a workday.
Pacifica Island Vanilla
Notes: Vanilla, coconut, pistachio, caramel, sandalwood. Who it is for: Those who want a softer, more natural take on Cheirosa 62. Ideal for daily wear, especially in warmer months. Verdict: Best Value
Pacifica is known for clean, affordable scents, and Island Vanilla is a gem. It’s less sweet than Cheirosa 62 but has a similar creamy pistachio-vanilla core. The coconut adds a tropical twist that reminds me of beach days. For the price, you get a surprisingly sophisticated fragrance that layers well with other scents. I keep a bottle in my bag for touch-ups.
Skylar Vanilla Sky
Notes: Vanilla, caramel, pistachio, amber, sandalwood. Who it is for: Fragrance enthusiasts who appreciate a more complex, niche-style profile. Perfect for evening wear or when you want a sophisticated gourmand. Verdict: Best Niche
Skylar’s Vanilla Sky elevates the pistachio-caramel concept. It opens with a burst of warm vanilla, then settles into a creamy, nutty heart with hints of pistachio. The amber and sandalwood base give it a grown-up feel. It’s pricier than other dupes but still more affordable than many niche brands. A little goes a long way, so the bottle lasts.
Mix:Bar Vanilla Bourbon
Notes: Vanilla, bourbon, caramel, sandalwood, musk. Who it is for: Budget-conscious shoppers who want a warm, boozy twist on the original. Great for date nights and cooler weather. Verdict: Best Budget
Mix:Bar is my go-to when I need a cheap thrill. Vanilla Bourbon doesn’t have pistachio, but the vanilla-caramel-bourbon combo evokes the same sweet, intoxicating vibe. The bourbon note adds a grown-up edge that distinguishes it from Cheirosa 62. At this price point, you can spray generously without guilt. I layer it with a pistachio body oil for an exact match.
Dossier Gourmand Vanilla
Notes: Vanilla, pistachio, caramel, tonka, musk. Who it is for: Fans of the original who want a refined, less synthetic version. A perfect everyday scent that’s office-safe. Verdict: Editor’s Pick
Dossier’s interpretation is a more elegant, airy version of Cheirosa 62. It keeps the pistachio and caramel but tones down the sweetness, making it less cloying. The tonka and vanilla round it out nicely. I find it lasts longer than the original and projects well without being too loud. It’s my personal favorite for work.
How to Choose
When looking for a dupe, focus on the dominant notes: pistachio, salted caramel, and vanilla. The Body Shop Vanilla Pumpkin is the closest all-rounder. For a clean option, Pacifica Island Vanilla is unbeatable. If you want niche quality, Skylar Vanilla Sky delivers. Mix:Bar Vanilla Bourbon is the best for tight budgets, and Dossier Gourmand Vanilla offers a refined take. Always test on skin before committing, as body chemistry affects how each scent develops. Check Amazon for price comparisons, especially for Dossier and Skylar, which sometimes have flash sales.
