Top Pick at a Glance
After testing countless alternatives, I’m confidently naming Afnan 9 PM as the best overall dupe for YSL Y EDP. It captures the signature apple-sage freshness while adding a warm ambery base that lasts all day. For under a tenth of the price, you get 90% similarity and better performance. I’ve been wearing it for weeks, and even fragrance enthusiasts can’t tell the difference in a blind test. Check the current price on Amazon, you’ll be amazed.
Check the current price on Amazon
Afnan 9 PM
Notes: Apple, Sage, Cinnamon, Amber, Vanilla, Musk
Who it’s for: Anyone who loves YSL Y EDP’s sweet-fresh DNA but wants better longevity and projection. Perfect for nights out or cooler days when you want the scent to last.
Verdict: Best Overall
This is the closest I’ve found to YSL Y EDP in the affordable category. The opening is identical, that crisp apple and sage combo, then it dries down to a warmer, slightly spicier base thanks to cinnamon and amber. It projects strongly for 2-3 hours and lasts 8+ hours on skin. The only difference? It’s a touch sweeter, which I actually prefer. If you want the YSL Y experience without the price tag, this is it.
Lattafa Fakhar Black
Notes: Apple, Ginger, Lavender, Sage, Vetiver, Musk
Who it’s for: Those who want a fresher, more aromatic take on YSL Y EDP. Great for office and daytime wear.
Verdict: Best Value
At around a fraction of the cost, Fakhar Black delivers a clean, soapy version of YSL Y EDP. The apple and sage are there, but the ginger and lavender add a sparkling, almost aquatic freshness. It’s lighter than the original, making it perfect for hot summer days or casual wear. Performance is moderate, about 4-5 hours, but for the price, you can overspray guilt-free. It’s my go-to for when I want to smell fresh without the expense.
Maison Alhambra Fierte
Notes: Apple, Bergamot, Sage, Cedar, Amber, Musk
Who it’s for: Fans of the woody base in YSL Y EDP who want a budget-friendly option with a touch more sophistication.
Verdict: Best Niche
Maison Alhambra is known for high-quality clones, and Fierte is a hidden gem. It emphasizes the cedar and amber notes from YSL Y EDP, making it woodier and less sweet. The opening is a burst of bergamot and apple, then dries down to a smooth, creamy wood. It smells more expensive than it is, I’ve gotten compliments from strangers who thought it was a niche perfume. Lasts 6-7 hours with moderate projection. If you like the structure of YSL Y but want something a bit more refined, this is your pick.
Al Haramain Amber Oud Carbon
Notes: Apple, Sage, Lavender, Amber, Woody Notes, Vanilla
Who it’s for: Those who crave maximum longevity and projection. Best for evening events or when you want to make a statement.
Verdict: Editor’s Pick
This is the beast mode dupe. Amber Oud Carbon amplifies everything you love about YSL Y EDP, the apple, sage, and amber are all present, but with added oud and vanilla that give it a richer, darker profile. It’s not a perfect clone; it’s an interpretation. But the quality is outstanding. One spray fills a room and lasts 10+ hours. I wear this when I want to be noticed. It’s a bit more expensive than other dupes but still a steal compared to the original. For my fellow longevity lovers, this is a must-try.
Pendora Scents The Pride of Armaf
Notes: Apple, Ginger, Sage, Cypress, Amber, Musk
Who it’s for: Budget-conscious shoppers who still want the YSL Y EDP vibe. Perfect for everyday wear and layering.
Verdict: Best Budget
If you’re looking for the cheapest option that still smells good, this is it. The Pride of Armaf opens with a sharp apple-ginger combo that mellows into a sage and cypress heart. It’s not as complex as the original, but it captures the fresh scent profile. Performance is about 3-4 hours, but you can reapply without guilt. I keep a decant in my bag for freshening up. For the price, it’s a fantastic entry point into fragrance dupes.
How to Choose
When looking for a dupe for YSL Y EDP, focus on the key notes: apple, sage, and amber. Sweeter versions (like Afnan 9 PM) are better for cold weather and nightlife, while fresher takes (like Lattafa Fakhar Black) work for summer and office. Consider performance: if you need all-day longevity, go for Al Haramain Amber Oud Carbon. Budget? Pendora Scents is your friend. Always check recent reviews and prices on Amazon before buying, some dupes fluctuate in price. And remember, a dupe doesn’t have to be an exact copy to be enjoyable; a good interpretation can become your new signature.
Prices and availability may vary. Always verify current listings on Amazon.
