The best lengthening mascaras: A stylist's guide to longer-looking lashes
For truly longer-looking lashes, reach for a tubing mascara like Thrive Causemetics Liquid Lash Extensions or a fiber-infused formula such as L'Oreal Bambi Eyes. These physically extend each lash with polymers or microfibers, giving you up to 40% more visible length without clumping. Avoid water-resistant formulas that tend to smudge; instead, look for "easily removableâ" on the label.
How to choose a lengthening mascara based on your lash type
Short, straight lashes: Go with a fiber mascara like Too Faced Better Than Sex (the original, not waterproof) which has a tapered brush to coat each lash in length-enhancing fibers. Use a lash comb to separate after application. Sparse lashes: Pick a formula with a skinny, plastic bristle brush such as Dior Show Pull-Out. The precise comb grabs every hair and stretches it out. Fine lashes: Try a gel-based lengthening mascara like Glossier Lash Slick. It adds length without weight, keeping lashes lifted all day.
Application techniques for maximum length
Start with a lash primer like Lancome Cils Booster XL. For lengthening, hold the wand vertically and wiggle at the roots, then pull straight upward. Apply two thin coats rather than one thick one. Wait 15 seconds between coats. Focus the second coat on the tips only. For lower lashes, use a mini brush (like the one in Benefit Roller Lash) to prevent smudges. Curl your lashes with a heated curler before mascara for extra reach.
The best lengthening mascaras for different occasions
Everyday wear: Tower 28 MakeWaves - a clean, lengthening mascara that holds a curl. It gives a natural, lifted look. LBR (long brunch) weekend: Rare Beauty Perfect Strokes. The tapered brush lets you build length on outer corners for a cat-eye effect. Night out: Pat McGrath Labs FetishEyes (not the waterproof version). Its fiber brush adds dramatic length with zero flakes. Travel-friendly: Travel minis of Dior Show Pull-Out or Travel Minis of Benefit Fan Fest (both come in smaller tubes that fit a clutch).
Styling your mascara with your makeup look
Pair long lashes with a matte eyeshadow in neutral tones to let the lashes stand out. For a monochromatic look, use a lengthening mascara in a shade that matches your eyeliner (e.g., brown mascara with a brown pencil). Avoid eyeliner on the waterline if you're using heavy lengthening mascara, as it can make lashes look spidery. Instead, tightline with a gel liner in a dark shade.
How to remove lengthening mascara without damaging lashes
Use a bi-phase makeup remover like Garnier Micellar Water (the blue cap version for waterproof makeup). Soak a cotton pad and hold against lashes for 30 seconds, then gently wipe downward. Do not rub back and forth. For tubed mascaras, warm water and a gentle massage will slide the tubes off intact. Never pull or tug, as this can lead to lash breakage. Follow with a lash conditioner or castor oil at night.
Key Takeaway
For dramatic length, choose a tubing or fiber mascara, apply with a vertical wiggle, and always pair with a lash primer for maximum extension.
