Quick Verdict
Very Good Girl wins if you love a bold, feminin-forward scent with red berry and vetiver depth. It’s a statement maker for date nights and special events. Montblanc Legend, however, is the reliable choice for men who want a crisp, professional fougere that works daily. Both are well-made, but they target very different people and occasions.
Check the current price on Amazon
Scent Profile Compared
Carolina Herrera Very Good Girl opens with a burst of tart red currant and litchi, juicy and sparkling. The heart is a lush rose absolute, velvety and rich, not powdery. The base is where it gets interesting: vetiver, praline, and vanilla create a creamy, earthy dry-down that’s surprisingly addictive. Contrast that with Montblanc Legend, which starts with lavender, bergamot, and pineapple leaf - a fresh, aromatic blast. Its heart is a classic fougere of geranium, coumarin, and oakmoss, leading to a dry-down of sandalwood, tonka, and musk. Legend is clean, masculine, and straightforward; Very Good Girl is complex, fruity-floral with a gourmand twist.
Longevity and Sillage
Very Good Girl projects strongly for the first 2-3 hours, then settles to a moderate aura for another 4-5 hours, giving about 7-8 hours total. It leaves a noticeable trail. Montblanc Legend is more moderate: about 1-2 hours of good projection, then a skin scent for 4-5 hours, total 6-7 hours. Neither is beast mode, but Very Good Girl has more presence and longevity for a date night or evening out. Legend is better for office or gym wear where subtlety is appreciated.
Best Occasions and Seasons
Very Good Girl shines in fall and winter evenings - think romantic dinners, parties, or date nights. The sweet, warm base feels cozy in cold weather, but the fruity opening can work in spring too. It’s not ideal for formal offices or scorching summer days. Montblanc Legend is a year-round workhorse: fresh enough for spring/summer with its aromatic top, but the woody-musk base transitions into fall. Perfect for office, gym, casual outings, even job interviews. It’s less romantic, more professional and accessible.
Price and Value
Check current price on Amazon to compare: Very Good Girl is often positioned at a higher price point due to its niche-like complexity and luxury branding. Legend is more affordable, frequently discounted. For the price, Legend offers solid performance for everyday wear. Very Good Girl feels more premium - the bottle alone is a statement - but if you’re budget-conscious, Legend gives you more bang for your buck in versatility and wearability. Always check current price on Amazon before buying.
Which Should You Buy?
Buy Very Good Girl if you’re a woman who loves compliments and wants a seductive, memorable scent for evenings and special events. It’s bold, unique, and not for the shy. Buy Montblanc Legend if you’re a man (or unisex lovers) who needs a reliable, clean, and professional daily driver that works in almost any situation without overwhelming. For women wanting a masculine-leaning fresh scent, Legend works as a unisex option. For men wanting something daring, look elsewhere - Legend is safe but predictable. In short: Very Good Girl for statement, Legend for staple.
