Quick Verdict
Creed Green Irish Tweed is the overall winner for its refined, versatile scent that works year-round and commands compliments. But if you crave a warm, smoky gourmand for cold evenings or date nights, By the Fireplace is a compelling alternative. I've worn both extensively, and while Green Irish Tweed feels like a signature scent, By the Fireplace is a mood piece.
Check the current price on Amazon
Scent Profile Compared
Creed Green Irish Tweed opens with a burst of lemon verbena and iris, but the star is the green, grassy accord of Galbanum and violet leaves. It's often compared to Davidoff Cool Water but is much more natural and complex. The heart reveals sandalwood and ambergris, giving it a clean, slightly floral woody base. The dry-down is a smooth, green-musk with a hint of cedar. It's crisp, fresh, and impeccably blended.
Maison Margiela Replica By the Fireplace is entirely different. It opens with pink pepper and orange blossom, but quickly transitions to a smoky, sweet heart of clove, chestnut, and guaiac wood. The star is the "burnt woodâ" and vanilla accord that smells like a bonfire on a cold night. The dry-down is a cozy, sweet vanilla with a touch of cashmeran and resinous notes. It's more linear than Green Irish Tweed but incredibly evocative.
Longevity and Sillage
Green Irish Tweed lasts 6-8 hours on my skin with moderate projection for the first 2 hours, then settles closer. It leaves a noticeable trail without being overwhelming. On clothes, it can linger for over a day.
By the Fireplace is shorter-lived: 4-6 hours on skin with a soft to moderate sillage. It projects well for the first hour, then becomes a skin scent. Its intimate nature makes it better for close encounters than making a grand entrance.
Best Occasions and Seasons
Green Irish Tweed is a spring and summer powerhouse, but its clean greenness works in fall too. It's ideal for office, brunch, weddings, or any setting where you want to smell sophisticated and fresh. It's not a winter scent.
By the Fireplace is strictly fall and winter. It's perfect for evenings by the fire, holiday parties, date nights, or cozy days. It can feel cloying in warm weather or formal settings.
Price and Value
Green Irish Tweed is a luxury niche fragrance with a high price tag. You pay for the Creed heritage and quality ingredients. By the Fireplace is much more affordable, a designer price point that's accessible. You can check current price on Amazon to compare, but Green Irish Tweed is an investment, while By the Fireplace is a bargain for its uniqueness.
Which Should You Buy?
Buy Creed Green Irish Tweed if you want a signature scent that's versatile, classy, and gets you compliments. It's worth the splurge for the man (or woman) who wants a refined, green fragrance that works almost anywhere.
Buy Maison Margiela Replica By the Fireplace if you love gourmands and want a cozy, comforting scent for cold weather. It's fantastic for casual wear and date nights, and it's a conversation starter. It's also a safer blind buy due to its lower price.
If budget is no object, Green Irish Tweed is the better long-term investment. But By the Fireplace is the better deal for its warmth and personality.
