Quick Verdict

Le Labo Another 13 is the clear winner for my personal taste, but let's be honest: Very Good Girl is the better value and more versatile for most people. Another 13 is a chameleon-like ambroxan bomb that smells different on everyone, while Very Good Girl is a confident, red-currant-laced rose that never misses. If you want a signature scent that feels like a second skin, pick Another 13. If you want a compliment-getter that lasts all day, go with Very Good Girl.

Check the current price on Amazon

Scent Profile Compared

Le Labo Another 13: The notes are a minimalist's dream: ambroxan, moss, jasmine, and a touch of iso e super (though they don't list it, you can smell the DNA). The opening is a clean, almost synthetic burst of ambroxan, salty, musky, and slightly metallic. It dries down to a warm, woody, skin-like scent that feels intimate and addictive. There's a faint floral sweetness from the jasmine, but it's mostly about that transparent, velvety musk. It's the kind of scent that makes you sniff your own wrist repeatedly.

Carolina Herrera Very Good Girl: This is a punchy, modern floral. Top notes are red currant and lychee, creating a tart, juicy opening that immediately grabs attention. The heart is a lush rose (the brand says it's a 'good girl' rose) with a hint of almond and saffron for warmth. The base is vanilla, patchouli, and cedar. As it dries down, the fruitiness fades into a creamy, slightly powdery rose with a woody backbone. It's more straightforward than Another 13, you know exactly what you're getting: sweet, fruity, floral, and undeniably feminine.

Longevity and Sillage

Le Labo Another 13: On my skin, it lasts 6-8 hours, but the sillage is intimate. It sits close to the skin, becoming a personal scent bubble. Some people complain it fades quickly, but I find it lingers as a soft skin scent all day. Reapplication might be needed for evening events. It's not a projection monster; it's a discovery scent.

Carolina Herrera Very Good Girl: This is a beast. I get 8-10 hours with moderate to strong sillage. Two sprays and I get compliments all day. The opening is loud, but it settles into a comfortable aura that lasts well into the night. If you want your perfume to be noticed, Very Good Girl delivers. It's one of the best-performing designer florals I've tested.

Best Occasions and Seasons

Le Labo Another 13: Year-round, but shines in cooler months. The warm ambroxan and moss work beautifully in fall and winter, but the clean nature makes it wearable in spring. It's perfect for office, date nights, and intimate gatherings. It's not a party scent; it's a subtle statement for when you want to be noticed only up close.

Carolina Herrera Very Good Girl: Best for spring and summer due to the bright fruit and floral notes. It's a day-to-night scent for brunch, shopping, or happy hour. The sweetness makes it less ideal for formal boardrooms, but it's great for casual outings and romantic dates. It's a scent that says "I'm here.â"

Price and Value

Let's talk value. Le Labo Another 13 is a niche price point, you're paying for the brand and the minimalist aesthetic. The 50ml bottle is a significant investment. Carolina Herrera Very Good Girl is more accessible, often available at a fraction of the cost. For the performance, Very Good Girl offers better value: you get more longevity and sillage for less. However, Another 13 has a unique, artisanal quality that justifies its price for fragrance enthusiasts. To get the best deal on either, I always check current price on Amazon, prices fluctuate, so it's worth a quick look before buying.

Which Should You Buy?

Buy Le Labo Another 13 if you: appreciate subtle, skin-like scents; want a fragrance that feels personal and ever-changing; prefer a unisex option; are a niche collector; or want a scent that won't overwhelm an office. It's for the person who wears fragrance for themselves.

Buy Carolina Herrera Very Good Girl if you: want a bold, long-lasting floral; need a compliment magnet; prefer sweet, fruity scents; have a tighter budget; or want a versatile day-to-night perfume. It's for the person who wants to make an entrance.