Le Labo Another 13 vs Maison Margiela Replica By the Fireplace: Which Perfume Is Better?

Quick Verdict

If you want a perfume that turns heads with a cozy, fireside warmth, Maison Margiela Replica By the Fireplace is your winner. But if you prefer a softer, skin-like scent that adapts to any situation and draws people in without shouting, Le Labo Another 13 takes the crown. I wear By the Fireplace for cold nights and casual get-togethers, but Another 13 is my daily driver. Both are excellent, but they serve very different purposes.

Check the current price on Amazon

Scent Profile Compared

Le Labo Another 13 opens with a blast of synthetic ambroxan and jasmine, creating a clean, almost metallic freshness. It’s not floral in the traditional sense; instead, it’s airy and slightly sweet, with a hint of green from moss and a musky base that smells like clean skin. The dry-down is where the magic happens: iso e super and ambroxan meld into a subtle, magnetic aura that’s hard to pin down. It’s intimate but present, like second skin.

Maison Margiela Replica By the Fireplace is the opposite. It hits you with a smoky, sweet burst of pink pepper and orange blossoms, but that’s quickly overtaken by chestnut, clove oil, and a rich cashmeran and vanilla base. The opening is like stepping into a cabin where a fire has just been stoked, warm, spicy, and slightly boozy. As it dries, the guaiac wood and creamy vanilla take center stage, turning into a toasted, sweet comfort scent that lingers like a cashmere blanket.

Key difference: Another 13 is abstract and transparent; By the Fireplace is literal and dense. One whispers, the other announces.

Longevity and Sillage

Le Labo Another 13 gives me about 6-8 hours on skin, but it’s a close-projection fragrance. The sillage is moderate at first, then settles into a personal bubble that people notice only when they’re close. I’ve had coworkers lean in to ask what I’m wearing. It’s not a beast, but it’s persistent in a quiet way.

By the Fireplace is louder. I get 7-9 hours of wear, with good projection for the first 3-4 hours. People will smell you from across the room. It eventually settles down but remains detectable for the rest of the day. On clothes, I’ve caught whiffs the next morning. If you want to fill a room, this is your pick.

Verdict: By the Fireplace wins on strength and longevity, but Another 13’s subtlety is its own superpower.

Best Occasions and Seasons

Le Labo Another 13 is a year-round, any-occasion scent. It works in the office because it’s not intrusive. It works on a date because it’s magnetic. It works in summer heat because it doesn’t suffocate. I wear it to meetings, brunch, and even the gym, it just adapts. The only time I skip it is deep winter, where it might feel too thin.

By the Fireplace is a seasonal specialist. It’s perfect for fall and winter, especially in the evening. Think bonfire parties, holiday gatherings, a cozy dinner, or a movie night on the couch. It’s too heavy for hot days and might feel cloying in a busy office. But for its intended mood, it’s unbeatable.

Bottom line: Another 13 is your everyday wardrobe staple; By the Fireplace is your special-occasion cozy scent.

Price and Value

Both sit in the luxury niche category. Le Labo Another 13 comes in a standard 50ml or 100ml size, while Maison Margiela Replica By the Fireplace is available in a range including travel sizes. Neither is cheap, but By the Fireplace feels more accessible as a scent experience because it’s such a clear mood. Another 13 is more abstract, and some might find it harder to justify the cost for something so subtle. I’d recommend checking current price on Amazon to compare based on your budget. Both hold value in their uniqueness.

Which Should You Buy?

Buy Le Labo Another 13 if you want a signature scent that works everywhere, office, gym, date night, year-round. You appreciate subtlety and want something that smells like clean skin but better. It’s for the person who wants to be remembered without trying.

Buy Maison Margiela Replica By the Fireplace if you want a cozy, smoky gourmand that’s perfect for cold months and special evenings. You love when people comment on your perfume. It’s for the person who wants to set a mood.

If you can afford both, get Another 13 as your daily and By the Fireplace for those chilly nights. If you’re picking one, ask yourself: do I want to smell like a person or a place?