Quick Verdict

Tom Ford Lost Cherry is the overall winner for those who want a bold, intoxicatingly unique cherry scent that feels luxurious and mysterious. It’s a masterpiece of boozy sweetness with a hint of almond creaminess. However, Carolina Herrera Very Good Girl is a fantastic alternative if you prefer a brighter, more playful fragrance that’s easier to wear daily. It’s a tart, sparkling litchi and rose combo that garners compliments. So, if you crave drama and depth, pick Lost Cherry. For a versatile, happy-go-lucky scent, go with Very Good Girl.

Check the current price on Amazon

Scent Profile Compared

Tom Ford Lost Cherry opens with a burst of black cherry, cherry liqueur, and a touch of bitter almond. This is not a candy-like cherry; it’s dark, jammy, and almost boozy. The heart reveals Turkish rose and jasmine sambac, adding a floral sophistication that balances the fruit. The dry-down is where the magic happens: peru balsam, roasted tonka, sandalwood, and cedar create a warm, creamy, slightly smoky base that lingers beautifully.

Carolina Herrera Very Good Girl opens with a zesty burst of red currant and litchi. The litchi is particularly juicy, almost effervescent, like a sparkling wine. The heart is a bouquet of Centifolia rose (May rose) and a touch of pink peppercorn for spice. The base is cleaner and more modern: vanilla, cedar, and ambroxan. The overall effect is a tart, fruity-floral that feels youthful and energetic.

Key difference: Lost Cherry is dark, syrupy, and complex; Very Good Girl is bright, fizzy, and straightforward.

Longevity and Sillage

Tom Ford Lost Cherry has excellent longevity on my skin, lasting 7-9 hours with moderate to strong sillage. It projects well for the first 3 hours, then settles into a close but noticeable skin scent. The cherry booziness lingers pleasantly.

Carolina Herrera Very Good Girl lasts around 5-7 hours, which is average for an eau de parfum. The sillage is moderate, but it doesn’t project as strongly as Lost Cherry. It’s more intimate, especially after the first 2 hours.

Winner: Lost Cherry for longevity and projection. Very Good Girl is fine for daily wear but requires reapplication for evenings.

Best Occasions and Seasons

Tom Ford Lost Cherry is a night-out, date-night, cold-weather scent. Its richness makes it perfect for fall and winter. Wear it to a fancy dinner or a romantic evening. It’s not ideal for the office or hot summer days.

Carolina Herrera Very Good Girl is incredibly versatile. It shines in spring, summer, and early fall. It’s perfect for brunch, shopping, daytime events, or even casual office wear. The fruity-floral vibe is uplifting and not overwhelming.

Recommendation: If you want one scent for special occasions, choose Lost Cherry. If you need an everyday signature scent, Very Good Girl.

Price and Value

Tom Ford Lost Cherry is a premium, niche-level fragrance with a price to match. It’s an investment piece. Carolina Herrera Very Good Girl is more accessible and often found at discounters. Both are available at major retailers and you can check current price on Amazon to compare deals.

Value-wise, Lost Cherry offers a unique, complex scent that stands out in a crowd. Very Good Girl delivers a crowd-pleasing experience at a lower cost. Decide which factor matters more to you.

Which Should You Buy?

Buy Tom Ford Lost Cherry if you’re a fragrance enthusiast who loves dark, boozy, sensual scents for evening wear and don’t mind spending more for artistry. Buy Carolina Herrera Very Good Girl if you want a fun, bright, easy-to-wear scent for daytime that garners compliments without breaking the bank. Both are excellent, but your choice depends on your lifestyle and budget.

Check current price on Amazon for the best deal.