Quick Verdict

If you want clean, sophisticated elegance that turns heads subtly, go with Creed Green Irish Tweed. If you prefer a loud, sweetly fresh scent that screams confidence and compliments, YSL Y EDP is your best bet. Both are excellent, but they suit different personalities. Green Irish Tweed is the refined classic; Y EDP is the modern party-starter. For most people under 30 who want instant appeal, Y EDP wins. For those seeking timeless class, Green Irish Tweed takes the crown.

Check the current price on Amazon

Scent Profile Compared

YSL Y EDP opens with a burst of green apple, ginger, and bergamot. It's sharp, sweet, and slightly spicy, very fizzy and energetic. The heart brings sage, juniper berries, and lavender, adding an aromatic complexity that's still very youthful. The base is woody with ambergris, cedar, and a synthetic tonka-like sweetness (from the "fir balsamâ" accord). The dry-down stays quite linear: sweet, ambered, and clean-laundry-like with a metallic edge.

Creed Green Irish Tweed opens with a legendary combination of lemon verbena and iris, creating a green, soapy-clean freshness. The heart is violet leaf and sandalwood, giving a slightly floral-woody nuance. The base is ambergris (Creed's signature), sandalwood, and a touch of oakmoss. Compared to Y EDP, Green Irish Tweed is more subtle, natural-smelling, and complex. The dry-down becomes a soft, grassy-musk with a salty ambergris warmth. It's less sweet and more mature, think fresh linen in a meadow.

Both are in the "freshâ" family, but Y EDP is louder and sweeter; Green Irish Tweed is softer and greener.

Longevity and Sillage

YSL Y EDP is a beast. On my skin, it lasts 8-10 hours with moderate projection for the first 3 hours. It projects a foot or two prominent, then settles to a skin scent. Sillage is strong, you'll get noticed. It's a compliment machine.

Creed Green Irish Tweed is more moderate. Expect 5-7 hours longevity. The projection is mild-moderate, intimate for the first 2 hours, then quite close to skin. It doesn't fill a room, but it creates a refined, personal aura. Sillage is softer, which makes it appropriate for close-quarters settings.

If you want all-day projection, Y EDP wins. If you prefer subtle elegance that fades gracefully, Green Irish Tweed is better.

Best Occasions and Seasons

YSL Y EDP shines in casual settings: nights out, dates, parties, college, or club wear. It's best in spring and summer, but its sweetness works in cooler weather too. Avoid for formal events or office, it can be too loud.

Creed Green Irish Tweed is versatile: office, weddings, formal dinners, first dates, or any time you want to smell sophisticated without screaming. Ideal for spring and fall, but works year-round. It's a true all-rounder for the professional or gentleman.

Price and Value

Green Irish Tweed is significantly more expensive, it's a luxury niche fragrance. You pay for the heritage, natural ingredients, and subtlety. YSL Y EDP is designer-priced, much more accessible. Y EDP also gives you more bang for your buck in terms of performance. However, Green Irish Tweed's scent is more complex and unique. Check current price for both on Amazon to see the gap.

Which Should You Buy?

Buy YSL Y EDP if you're under 30, want to be noticed, love sweet-fresh scents that project, and want a budget-friendly daily driver. Buy Creed Green Irish Tweed if you appreciate subtlety, elegance, and a timeless green profile, and are willing to pay for it. If you can afford both, get Green Irish Tweed for special occasions and Y EDP for everyday.

For a hybrid option, consider YSL Y Le Parfum for deeper sweetness plus class, but that's another story.