Quick Verdict

Creed Silver Mountain Water is the more refined, unique scent, but YSL Y EDP is the better all-around performer for daily wear. If you want a versatile, crowd-pleasing blue fragrance with strong projection, go with YSL Y EDP. If you crave a sophisticated, metallic aquatic that stands out in a subtle way, choose Creed Silver Mountain Water. For most people, YSL Y EDP offers better value and usability.

Check the current price on Amazon

Scent Profile Compared

YSL Y EDP opens with a sharp burst of green apple, ginger, and bergamot. It's fresh, slightly sweet, and very energetic. As it dries down, the synthetic ambergris, cedar, and a touch of tonka bean create a warm, woody base that sticks close to the skin after a few hours. The overall vibe is modern, youthful, and loud, perfect for nights out or when you want to be noticed.

Creed Silver Mountain Water starts with a zesty blend of bergamot, mandarin, and a hint of blackcurrant. The heart is an unusual mix of green tea and a metallic accord that smells like fresh mountain air. The base features sandalwood and musk, giving it a soft, clean finish. It's more subtle and refined than YSL Y EDP, with a distinctive "inkyâ" quality that's rarely found in designer scents.

Both are fresh, but in very different ways. YSL Y EDP is sweet and synthetic; Silver Mountain Water is crisp and natural-smelling.

Longevity and Sillage

YSL Y EDP lasts 6-8 hours on my skin, with moderate-to-strong projection for the first 2-3 hours. It leaves a noticeable trail but doesn't fill a room. On clothes, it can last 10+ hours.

Creed Silver Mountain Water lasts 4-6 hours on skin with soft to moderate projection. It's more of a skin scent after the first hour. On clothes, it fades faster than YSL Y EDP. For longevity lovers, YSL Y EDP is the clear winner.

Best Occasions and Seasons

YSL Y EDP shines in spring, fall, and cooler summer nights. It's perfect for parties, dates, or any social event where you want to be noticed. Office-safe in small doses, but the sweetness can be cloying in high heat.

Creed Silver Mountain Water is ideal for warm weather, especially summer days. Its clean, metallic freshness works well in office settings, formal events, or any situation where subtlety is key. It's also excellent for travel, never overbearing.

Price and Value

Creed Silver Mountain Water costs significantly more than YSL Y EDP. But price doesn't always equal value. YSL Y EDP gives you strong performance and a versatile scent at a much lower cost. Silver Mountain Water offers a unique, high-quality scent experience with softer performance. I recommend checking current price on Amazon to see the difference for yourself.

Which Should You Buy?

Buy YSL Y EDP if: you want a loud, long-lasting blue fragrance that gets compliments, works for parties and casual wear, and fits a tighter budget. It's the safer, more practical choice.

Buy Creed Silver Mountain Water if: you value originality, subtlety, and a clean, metallic aquatic that stands out without shouting. It's perfect for collectors or anyone who prefers niche quality over crowd-pleasing projection.

My honest take: most people will be happier with YSL Y EDP. But if you can afford Creed Silver Mountain Water and appreciate its artistry, it's a worthy addition to any collection.