Quick Verdict

YSL Y EDP takes the crown. It’s a modern, citrus-woody powerhouse with better versatility, longevity, and distinctiveness. Montblanc Legend is a clean, classic fresh scent that’s undeniably likeable but less daring. If you want a fragrance that turns heads and lasts all day, go with Y EDP. If you prefer a familiar, mass-appealing scent for daily wear, Legend is a reliable choice.

Check the current price on Amazon

Scent Profile Compared

YSL Y EDP opens with a bright, zesty burst of bergamot and ginger, with a hint of apple. The heart is a clean sage and lavender combo, while the base is a woody-ambery blend of cedar and ambergris. It’s a modern fougère with a sharp, masculine edge. The dry-down is smooth, slightly sweet, and aromatic.

Montblanc Legend EDP opens with a citrusy (bergamot, grapefruit) and lavender accord, very reminiscent of classic fougères like Davidoff Cool Water or even a toned-down Aventus. The heart adds geranium and apple, and the base is sandalwood and tonka. It’s straightforward, clean, and pleasant. The dry-down becomes softer and creamier, with the woods and tonka taking over. Legend is less complex than Y EDP, but intentionally so, it’s a no-brainer fresh scent.

Longevity and Sillage

YSL Y EDP performs strongly. I get 7-9 hours on skin, with solid projection for the first 2-3 hours. It leaves a noticeable trail without being overwhelming. Montblanc Legend EDP lasts about 5-6 hours on me, with moderate projection that becomes a skin scent after 3 hours. Legend is more intimate; you won’t fill a room, but you’ll smell good up close. For longevity and sillage, Y EDP is the clear winner.

Best Occasions and Seasons

YSL Y EDP is incredibly versatile. It works year-round, from office to date nights, spring through fall. In summer, use a lighter spray. It’s confident enough for evenings, but fresh enough for daytime. A true all-rounder.

Montblanc Legend shines in warmer months and casual settings. It’s perfect for the office, gym, or everyday errands. In cold weather, it fades quickly. Best for spring/summer day wear when you want a simple, fresh scent. Not ideal for formal events or cold nights.

Price and Value

Montblanc Legend EDP is typically more affordable than YSL Y EDP, but prices vary. You can check current price on Amazon for both. Y EDP offers better longevity and uniqueness, so you may feel it’s worth the extra cost. Legend is a safe, budget-friendly option that delivers a classic scent profile. Neither is a bad value, it depends on your priorities.

Which Should You Buy?

Buy YSL Y EDP if: you want a modern, versatile scent that lasts all day, gets compliments, and stands out from typical freshies. Ideal for men 20-40 who like aromatic, woody fragrances with a twist.

Buy Montblanc Legend if: you’re on a budget, need a reliable daily driver, or prefer classic, inoffensive scents. Great for teens, office workers, or anyone who wants a safe, manly fresh fragrance without complexity.

In short, Y EDP is the better fragrance overall, more sophisticated, longer lasting, and more interesting. But Legend has its place as a no-fuss classic.