Quick Verdict
YSL Y EDP is the better fragrance overall. It’s a versatile, modern aromatic fougère that works for almost any occasion with solid performance. Sol de Janeiro Cheirosa 62 is a delicious gourmand that’s fun and affordable, but it’s less complex and has weaker longevity. Choose Y if you want a signature scent that turns heads; choose Cheirosa 62 if you want a playful body spray for casual days.
Check the current price on Amazon
Scent Profile Compared
YSL Y EDP opens with a bright, zesty burst of bergamot, ginger, and a hint of apple. The heart is a clean, aromatic blend of sage and lavender, with a subtle floral touch from geranium. The base is woody and ambery, featuring cedar, amberwood, and a touch of tonka. On my skin, the opening is fresh and invigorating, then it settles into a warm, slightly sweet woody scent that’s professional yet alluring. It’s a more mature, refined take on a fresh scent.
Sol de Janeiro Cheirosa 62 is a gourmand bomb from the get-go. Top notes are pistachio and salted caramel, which smell exactly like a buttery, nutty dessert. The heart adds heliotrope and jasmine, but they’re quickly overshadowed by the vanilla and sandalwood base. On my skin, it’s very linear and sweet, with a cozy, edible quality. It’s less about complexity and more about instant happy vibes. The dry-down remains vanillic and nutty, with a slight sunscreen-like warmth.
Key difference: YSL Y EDP is an aromatic, versatile scent that balances freshness with depth. Cheirosa 62 is a deliberately sweet, gourmand treat that prioritizes immediate appeal over subtlety.
Longevity and Sillage
YSL Y EDP lasts 6-8 hours on my skin, with moderate to strong sillage for the first 2-3 hours. It projects well without being overwhelming, leaving a noticeable scent trail. After 4 hours, it becomes a skin scent but still detectable up close. Excellent for an EDP.
Sol de Janeiro Cheirosa 62 is a perfumed body mist, so longevity is shorter. I get 2-4 hours before it fades to a faint whisper. The sillage is initially moderate but drops off quickly. Reapplication is needed for all-day wear. It’s not designed for longevity but for casual, frequent spritzing.
Verdict on performance: YSL Y EDP wins handily.
Best Occasions and Seasons
YSL Y EDP shines in spring, fall, and cooler summer evenings. It’s suitable for the office, date nights, and formal events. My go-to for client meetings or dinner outings where I want to smell polished and memorable. It can be worn year-round but blossoms in moderate temperatures.
Sol de Janeiro Cheirosa 62 is best for casual, warm-weather days. Beach trips, brunch with friends, or a lazy Sunday at home. It’s too sweet and linear for formal or work settings. In hot weather, the sweetness can become cloying, so I prefer it in spring and summer evenings. It’s a mood booster, not a power suit scent.
Price and Value
YSL Y EDP is a premium designer fragrance. It costs more upfront, but you get a well-crafted, long-lasting scent that needs fewer sprays. A bottle lasts months. Cheirosa 62 is a budget-friendly body spray. The price is much lower, but you’ll go through it faster due to weaker longevity. If you value quality and performance, YSL is better value per wear. If you like variety and frequent reapplication, Cheirosa 62 is a fun addition to your collection. Check current price on Amazon for both.
Which Should You Buy?
Buy YSL Y EDP if: You want a sophisticated, versatile signature scent that lasts all day. You need something for work, dates, and special occasions. You appreciate a complex, well-blended fragrance with real performance.
Buy Sol de Janeiro Cheirosa 62 if: You love sweet gourmands and want a playful, affordable everyday spray. You don’t mind reapplying and prefer a casual, happy scent. You’re looking for a gift for a teen or someone new to fragrance.
My bottom line: Keep YSL Y EDP as your reliable, high-quality workhorse. Cheirosa 62 is a delightful guilty pleasure for laid-back days. Both have their place, but if I had to pick one, YSL Y EDP wins for its versatility and polish.
