For most people the Hoka Speedgoat 5 is the one to buy: it is the best balance of comfort, performance and value in this group. If it is not quite right for you, the Salomon Speedcross 6 is the strong runner-up that suits a slightly different stride or budget.
Choosing a running shoe online is hard because every brand calls its foam responsive and every model is the most cushioned yet. What actually matters is a much shorter list, and we have done the legwork so you can skip straight to the pick that fits how you move.
Below are the options that consistently rise to the top across independent lab measurements and large pools of verified owner reviews. We have grouped them by the job each one does best, so you can jump to the right pick rather than reading all six.
Quick comparison
The picks, in detail
Hoka Speedgoat 5
The go-to cushioned trail shoe: grippy Vibram Megagrip and a soft ride for long days on technical trails.
- Excellent grip
- Cushioned for long miles
- Secure fit
- Narrow toe box
- Drains slowly when wet
Salomon Speedcross 6
Aggressive deep lugs make it the king of soft, muddy, technical terrain.
- Superb mud and soft-ground grip
- Secure Quicklace fit
- Tough build
- Lugs poor on hard pack
- Snug fit
Brooks Cascadia 18
A stable, protective do-everything trail shoe that handles mixed terrain and longer efforts.
- Stable on uneven ground
- Protective and durable
- Comfortable
- Heavy
- Average mud grip
Saucony Peregrine 14
A versatile, grippy trail shoe with PWRTRAC lugs that work across most terrain.
- Versatile all-terrain grip
- Responsive
- Good value
- Firm
- Less cushion for ultras
Nike Pegasus Trail 5
A door-to-trail crossover that runs smoothly on road and light trail alike.
- Smooth road-to-trail ride
- Comfortable
- Stylish
- Grip limited on technical mud
- Heavier
Salomon Sense Ride 5
Salomon's smooth, cushioned do-anything trail shoe that grips well without aggressive lugs.
- Smooth, versatile ride
- Good all-round grip
- Comfortable
- Not for deep mud
- Snug
How to choose
- Match lugs to terrain. Deep, aggressive lugs grip mud and soft ground; shallower lugs roll better on hard pack and door-to-trail runs.
- Protection vs weight. Rock plates and tougher uppers protect on technical ground but add weight. Pick for your typical trails.
- Waterproof or breathable. Gore-Tex keeps feet dry in wet and cold but runs hot; mesh drains and breathes better in summer.
- Fit and lockdown. Trails demand a secure heel and a toe box that lets toes splay on descents without sliding forward.
Shop by brand
Related guides
Frequently asked questions
How often should I replace running shoes?
Most trainers are good for roughly 300 to 500 miles. Replace them when the midsole stops bouncing back, the outsole wears smooth, or new aches appear. Rotating two pairs makes both last longer.
Should I size up?
Usually half a size up from your everyday shoe. Feet swell on runs and you want a thumb's width of room at the toe to avoid bruised toenails.
Is the Hoka Speedgoat 5 worth it?
For most buyers, yes. The Hoka Speedgoat 5 earned our top spot for offering the best overall balance in this group, which is why it is our first recommendation.
Some links are affiliate links and we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. Disclosure.