For most people the Merrell Moab 3 Mid WP is the one to buy: it is the best balance of comfort, performance and value in this group. If it is not quite right for you, the Salomon Quest 4 GTX is the strong runner-up that suits a slightly different stride or budget.
Choosing a hiking boot online is hard because every brand calls its foam responsive and every model is the most cushioned yet. What actually matters is a much shorter list, and we have done the legwork so you can skip straight to the pick that fits how you move. Wet weather demands a waterproof build and reliable grip, which shaped every choice below.
Below are the options that consistently rise to the top across independent lab measurements and large pools of verified owner reviews. We have grouped them by the job each one does best, so you can jump to the right pick rather than reading all six.
Quick comparison
The picks, in detail
Merrell Moab 3 Mid WP
The comfortable, affordable mid boot for day hikes and light backpacking.
- Comfortable out of the box
- Affordable
- Waterproof
- Average durability
- So-so wet grip
Salomon Quest 4 GTX
A supportive backpacking boot built to carry a heavy pack over long, rugged miles.
- Excellent ankle support
- Carries heavy loads well
- Waterproof, durable
- Heavy
- Stiff break-in
KEEN Targhee IV Mid WP
A roomy, waterproof mid boot with KEEN's wide fit and reliable all-round performance.
- Very roomy, wide fit
- Waterproof
- Good value
- Bulky
- Heavy
Lowa Renegade GTX Mid
A long-time favorite all-round leather boot praised for fit, support, and durability.
- Superb fit and support
- Very durable
- Waterproof
- Expensive
- Heavier
Danner Mountain 600
A handsome leather hiking boot that performs on trail and looks good in town.
- Stylish full-grain leather
- Comfortable Vibram sole
- Versatile
- Pricey
- Heavier
Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II
An affordable, comfortable waterproof boot ideal for beginners and casual hikers.
- Very affordable
- Comfortable and waterproof
- Good traction
- Less durable long-term
- Basic cushioning
How to choose
- Match support to your load. Day hikers want lighter mid boots; heavy multi-day packs need stiffer, more supportive boots with ankle protection.
- Waterproofing. A Gore-Tex or proprietary membrane keeps feet dry in wet terrain and shallow crossings, at the cost of some breathability.
- Break them in. Leather and stiffer boots need miles to mould to your feet. Never wear new boots on a big hike.
- Fit and ankle support. A locked-in heel and supportive cuff prevent rolled ankles on uneven ground; size up for thick socks.
Shop by brand
Related guides
Frequently asked questions
Do I need waterproof or breathable?
Waterproof membranes keep feet dry in wet, cold conditions but run warm. In hot, dry climates, breathable non-waterproof shoes are more comfortable and dry faster if soaked.
How should hiking footwear fit?
Snug in the heel and midfoot with room to wiggle toes. Try them on with hiking socks and size up if needed so toes do not jam on descents.
Is the Merrell Moab 3 Mid WP worth it?
For most buyers, yes. The Merrell Moab 3 Mid WP earned our top spot for offering the best overall balance in this group, which is why it is our first recommendation.
Some links are affiliate links and we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. Disclosure.